Hotel Sutter - Sutter Creek, California

Caroline P.

Had reservations for dinner and arrived early. We head down to the Copper Room for drinks before dinner. The ambiance was classy and fun down there. Bartender was well dressed and knew his craft. Cocktails were outstanding!

Dinner upstairs was 5-stars across the board. We had the Brussels to start, Crab Louie for me and New York for the SO. Everything was fresh, cooked perfectly, and the sides and sauces were thoughtfully made and presented. A really fabulous experience. It made our Casino steakhouse dinner from the night before feel like it was playing pretend in comparison.

Our server was Aaron and his table service was impeccable, he’s clearly passionate about the food and the Hotel itself and it really made the experience special.

Ambiance was unbeatable, the historic atmosphere was wonderful and with it being fall it made it festive and fun.

Highly recommend!

Petro M.

Last week, my wife and I decided to visit this establishment due to the large number of positive reviews it received in a very short time. As soon as we entered, we were greeted by a warm and cozy atmosphere. The staff welcomed us in a friendly manner and immediately asked where we would prefer to sit—at a table or the bar. We chose the bar.

We appreciated that they had no problem letting us taste different beers to help us decide what we wanted. The cocktails my wife ordered were prepared very professionally, quickly, and, most importantly, they had real flavor and a pleasant aftertaste—something you enjoy drinking.

The food also impressed us. It was delicious, without any unpleasant aftertaste or heaviness in the stomach. Additionally, we were very pleased with the cleanliness of the establishment. From the bar counter and utensils to the restroom, it was evident that cleanliness is a priority here.

The only unpleasant moment was when my wife had her second cocktail—we noticed that the glass it was served in was cracked (photo attached). Considering the dim lighting and the large number of guests, we understood this was unintentional. However, we strongly recommend inspecting all glasses after washing to avoid this in the future.

It would have been nice if the bartender had offered some sort of complimentary gesture from the establishment after such an incident—this would reflect the level of their customer service. Unfortunately, nothing was offered.

Overall, everything was good, and we left satisfied. Yes, we would recommend this place to our friends and would come back ourselves.

Allie L.

We have stayed in Sutter Creek a few times to see family and Hotel Sutter is a must for brunch, dinner, and drinks. We always have the highest quality service, the most fresh and delicious tasting food, and a beautiful view. The hotel is stunning inside and out. They keep it very clean, decorations all around, and it’s very cozy. There is restaurant, outside, and bar seating on the main floor, and there is a balcony with heaters on the second floor. The view of Main Street from all the different seating areas is beautiful at night, plus food and drinks are reasonable in price. The staff never disappoints and they are all so sweet!

Deedee C.

Had an amazing dinner at Hotel Sutter today! The filet mignon and salmon were DELICIOUS!! Gabby provided wonderful service and Duran was working his magic behind the bar... Pear Martini and Bees Knees, couldn't have been any better. Can't wait to go back!

luz K. P.

Danielle made our dining table experience memorable! She also recommended great appetizers and dessert. She made sure we had utensil's refilled drinks and made sure the food was delicious and well cooked. She had a positive attitude and made us feel comfortable.

Mac R.

Came in during a rainy day for lunch from Sacramento and sat at the bar. We’ve never been to this spot. Daron and Brandon were absolutely exceptional and really made our experience. So lively and full of energy which is hard to find these days. This is our new spot and we will be back!! Thank you for the incredible service and making it fun you two! 🙂

Connie L. L.

We come to Hotel Sutter for dinner every year and watch the parade! Danielle took very good care of us and provided excellent customer service. Our food was amazing too (Prime Rib & Braised Short Ribs). This town is amazing, with awesome people!

Casey B.

Absolutely loved my stay at Hotel Sutter! The rooms were charming and impeccably clean, creating a cozy atmosphere. The restaurant exceeded my expectations with a fantastic menu featuring fresh ingredients. Each dish was a delight, and the cocktails were wonderful. My date and I loved the passion fruit martini. A special shoutout to our server, Andrew—he was attentive and made our dining experience truly exceptional. Highly recommend this hotel for a wonderful getaway!