Painted Pony Restaurant - Bethlehem, Connecticut

Painted Pony Restaurant

About Painted Pony Restaurant

The Painted Pony Restaurant, located at 74 Main St S, Bethlehem, CT 06751, is a delightful American dining establishment that offers a wide range of delicious dishes and exceptional services. With a great selection of beers, cocktails, wines, and comfort food, this restaurant caters to various tastes and preferences.

Specialties and Services

• Outdoor seating for a lovely dining experience
• Takeout, dine-in, delivery options for convenience
• Fast service to cater to busy patrons
• Fireplace and cozy ambiance for a warm and inviting atmosphere
• Lively live music and sports broadcasts for entertainment
• Full-service bar onsite with a diverse selection of drinks
• Diverse menu options including lunch, dinner, small plates, and vegetarian options
• Catering services available for special events
• Comprehensive menu featuring a variety of desserts
• Free parking lot and free street parking available for customers

Opinions and Reviews

The Painted Pony Restaurant has garnered a impressive 4.3/5 average rating from its 340 Google My Business reviews, indicating that patrons highly appreciate its offerings and services. One notable review mentioned a pleasant experience during a visit after picking up pumpkins and apple cider doughnuts at March Farm in Bethlehem. The reviewer praised the cleanliness and good service, as well as the tasty and well-presented dishes. They also noted that the prices were reasonable and recommended giving the restaurant a try if in the area.

Contact Information

Phone: 203-266-5771

Website: paintedponyrestaurant.net

Recommendation

If you're searching for a delightful American dining experience with a great selection of beers, cocktails, wines, and comfort food, look no further than the Painted Pony Restaurant. This Bethlehem-based restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, with excellent service and a diverse menu to cater to a wide range of tastes. With its impressive Google My Business reviews and a 4.3/5 average rating, the Painted Pony Restaurant is definitely worth a visit. Don't hesitate to contact them through their website or by phone to make a reservation and experience their exceptional services firsthand.

👍 Reviews of Painted Pony Restaurant

Steve A.

4/5

We stopped here after our visit to March farm in Bethlehem where we picked up pumpkins and the best apple cider doughnuts. We stopped in at the Painted Pony around 3 in the afternoon . The place was empty which is a shame since it’s a good place . Everything was spotless and the service was good . My wife had the chicken avocado sandwich and a side salad , I had the flatbread topped with Asiago cheese, short rib and tomatoes. Both were presented well and tasty, nothing mind blowing but worth the money , if your in the area give it a try .

Valon S.

5/5

Amazing service is an understatement. The new painted pony restaurant is an amazing place for people of all Ages with events all through the week such as trivia on Tuesdays and bands every Saturday this place has it all. The amazing menu is only beat by the amazing food options. The fries are amazing and while there are many pasta dishes the chicken parm in particular is amazing don’t listen to what the haters say the painted pony is an amazing place for you and the whole family. I will be coming back.

Michael G. G.

2/5

appetizers were great but what I order steak tips I don't expect a steak cut into pieces those were not sirloin tips I asked for medium rare I got well my friend ordered a New York strip it was so fatty she complained was nice about it chef looks it up online to see how much fat should be on it so that tells me they are not a chef and did not honor giving another one and taken back the fat one so it cost me over $30 for the steak tips that were not sirloin steak tips overcooked and they were too cheap to honor the New York strip which she did not ask for her money back she just wanted another one your restaurant has went downhill again I have never heard of a so-called Chef to look up what a New York strip should be like let's call the sky a kitchen worker that has no concept of temping steak because you definitely screwed up my fake steak tips

Erich W.

5/5

A really great place oozing atmosphere.
Great food residency priced, with many drink options.
The specialty drinks were not priced and cost more then we'd expected at $12, but we're very well made.
Get the wings and the jalapeno dip (request extra jalapeno).
I'm told the calamari is very good as well.
Great attentive service, with smiles all around

Thomas H. I.

5/5

Awesome place for food, drinks, and music! The owner Missy is super friendly and extremely accommodating. The chef always has specials and are a great change from typical menu items at most places. The daily menu is diverse and everything I've had to date has been great. We love this place!

JENNEKEN R.

3/5

Service was great the food was ok. My baked fish was tuff and had no flavor and my broccoli was obviously frozen and water logged. Chicken parmesan was obviously premade, the tomatoe sauce was also not fresh or homemade. The place had a musty smell. The dining room looked refurbished. Good bread. Great service average food.

tarlea L.

3/5

Service was good .. food mediocre.. but what upset me the most was there was flies and one landed on my food.. won’t be back..

Brian L.

4/5

Food was very good, although it took too long to get it..
Entertainment was very good, overall we had a nice time.