Penny Lane Art Gallery and Cafe - New Carlisle, Ohio

Penny Lane Art Gallery and Cafe

Penny Lane Art Gallery and Cafe, located at 109 S Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344, is a unique and inviting space that seamlessly blends an art gallery with a cozy cafe and restaurant. The cafe specializes in offering a wide range of delicious coffee beverages, desserts, and teas, along with a diverse menu featuring breakfast, lunch, and small plates. With its welcoming atmosphere, Penny Lane Art Gallery and Cafe is the perfect spot to enjoy great food and drink while appreciating local and visiting artists' works.

Specialties and Offerings

• Cafe and Coffee Shop
• Art Gallery
• Restaurant

Guests can choose from a variety of seating options, including outdoor seating when the weather permits. The cafe also offers onsite services such as seating, restrooms, and free Wi-Fi for patrons to enjoy during their visit. As the name suggests, the art gallery showcases rotating exhibitions, featuring both local and traveling artists. Additionally, patrons can enjoy live music and performances at the cafe, enhancing the overall experience.

Points of Interest

• Women-owned business
• Outdoor seating
• Onsite services
• Takeout and dine-in options
• Delivery available
• Vegetarian options
• Healthy options
• Quick bites
• Comfort food
• Catering services
• Dessert selection
• Seating options
• Restroom facilities
• Wi-Fi
• Casual, cozy, and trendy atmosphere
• Suitable for college students, groups, and solo diners
• Accepts reservations
• Various payment options, including credit cards, NFC mobile payments, and debit cards
• High chairs and a kids' menu available
• Free parking lot and street parking
• Dogs allowed outside the cafe

Reviews and Opinions

Penny Lane Art Gallery and Cafe has received an impressive number of reviews on Google My Business, with a stellar average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars. Patrons praise the cafe's unique atmosphere, excellent coffee options, friendly service, and the diverse range of art showcased in the gallery. Many visitors appreciate the opportunity to enjoy a tasty meal or beverage while engaging with the local art community. Some guests mention that the cafe can get quite loud during peak hours, but this is generally not considered a significant drawback for most visitors. Overall, the majority of reviews highlight the cafe's ability to provide a comfortable, enjoyable, and artistic experience for patrons.

👍 Reviews of Penny Lane Art Gallery and Cafe

Chien P.

4/5

Came here on a mildly busy Saturday during lunch hours for some coffee. I got a caramel latte and some others got a flight. The cafe is of a decent size with a nice artsy atmosphere, but it can get rather loud with the crowd. Service is good with friendly staff. Many unique and seasonal flavors to choose from including a tasting flight. Although for my taste, the coffee tends to be on the sweeter side, somewhat overpowering the espresso. Recommend if you are looking for a place to have some fun chatting and trying out flavors, rather than the quality of the coffee itself.

Cassaundra W.

5/5

Cute little spot for a quick bite and some coffee. Downtown location is a little busy and parking was kinda stressful but worth it! So nice for a small town place with gluten free options as well.

Rebecca B.

5/5

This was my first time visiting Penny Lane. My son and his Scout Troop were selling popcorn at the Heritage of Flight Festival, and our booth was right out front. We needed a little something to fill our bellies and Penny Lane did the job. The marble brownie was super moist and rich. His panini was perfect. I believe that we will be going back.

Erika S.

5/5

Love Penny Lane! I've been enjoying coming here for years and am so glad that such a great coffee shop and cafe is in my hometown.

Angela P.

5/5

Such a cute little find. I love the atmosphere, the food was delicious. I ordered the Monet sandwich...highly recommend it!! The Pumkin Cookie Latte was fantastic. Will be back when I'm in town again.

Jillian D.

5/5

LOVE the atmosphere AND the coffee. My best friend and I come about once a week. We almost always get a flight and work while we are there and it's an excellent spot to do that in. Go for it, get the flight. You won't regret it.

Delaney M.

2/5

I’ve been here a few times, the food is always delicious and their seasonal menu / latte flights are always amazing. I realized one of the glasses in my flight was cracked and I made the cashier aware of it as I was leaving. she told me “it’s fine, we know about it, let’s hope it doesn’t crack any more.” I’ve been in food service for years, you CANNOT serve drinks in cracked glasses. you are putting your customers in serious danger. glasses crack, accidents happen, and I am not upset about receiving a cracked glass. but please discard them when you’re made aware of it, don’t keep the glass in rotation. I will be coming back because again, the food and drinks are always delicious. I hope to leave a better review in the future.

Emily B.

5/5

Penny Lane exceeds my expectations every single time I visit and I always can’t wait to go back! I have had a variety of their food and drinks and thoroughly enjoy them each and every time. The wait may be a bit longer when they are busy but it’s worth it! They truly care about what goes into their items and the atmosphere with the art is some of the best. Ditch Starbucks and make this your new coffee spot, you won’t regret it!